Trouble in Osprey Heaven

Every year during the spring time I visit the resident osprey colony at Lake Blue Cypress a couple of times during breeding season from March until May. Lake Blue Cypress is located in the middle of the state of Florida and got its name from the beautiful bald cypress trees that cover the edges of the round lake. The giant trees that stand in the water give you the feeling of traveling through a pre-historic scenery in a very peaceful ambiance.

Wounded osprey swimming with blood dripping from his nostrils. Canon 7D MkII, Canon EF 600mm/f4 MkII, 600mm, 1/125s at f7.1, ISO 400, handheld.

Other than a local fish camp, which is operated by the Middleton family, there is hardly any human activity around the lake, with the exception of a handful of fisherman in little boats. Oftentimes, you are completely alone and surrounded by the sound of nature, and a screaming osprey population.

  • sunrise-at-lake-blue-cypress_s6a6960-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Beautiful sunrise at Lake Blue Cypress. Canon EOS 5D MkII, Canon EF 24-70mm/f2.8 lens at 53mm, f6.3, 1/800s, ISO 200, handheld.

  • ospreys-nesting-on-cypress-tree_e7t1222-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Bald Cypress tree with Spanish moss and nesting ospreys. Canon EOS 1Dx, Canon EF 200-400mm/f4 lens with 1.4x TC at 280mm, f5.6, 1/1250s, ISO 800, handheld.

A large group of ospreys has chosen the lake as their annual breeding grounds. They love to nest on top of the cypress trees which gives them great protection and plenty of structure to build a solid nest. It is estimated that the total number of osprey pairs is in excess of 100. With hardly any natural predators, and water full of fish the lake provides a great place to nest and raise offspring.

  • osprey-landing-on-nest-with-fish_e7t0892-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey landing on the nest with a fish. Canon EOS 1Dx, Canon EF 200-400mm/f4 lens with 1.4x TC at 490mm, f5.6, 1/1600s, ISO 400, handheld.

  • osprey-landing-on-branch_e7t1153-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey landing on branch. Canon EOS 1Dx, Canon EF 200-400mm/f4 lens with 1.4x TC at 560mm, f5.6, 1/1000s, ISO 400, handheld.

  • osprey-flying-at-sunrise_s6a6971-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Sunrise with osprey flying. Canon EOS 5D MkII, Canon EF 24-70mm/f2.8 lens at 55mm, f6.3, 1/800s, ISO 200, handheld.

During the breeding season there is plenty of activity. Early in the season the birds are working hard to restore the nesting sites and bring in various building materials such as sticks, branches for the structure and softer materials such as Spanish moss and grasses for the lining.

  • cypress-trees-in-the-water_s6a7016-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Bald cypress trees at the lake edge. Canon EOS 5D MkII, Canon EF 24-70mm/f2.8 lens at 45mm, f5.6, 1/125s, ISO 400, handheld.

  • osprey-flying-with-large-fish_a3i0437-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey flying around with large fish in talons. Canon EOS 1Dx MkII, Canon EF 600mm/f4 lens and 1.4x TC at 840mm, f5.6, 1/1600s, ISO 640, handheld.

Ospreys are normally monogamous. One male mates with one female, and mating pairs stay together until one of them dies. The female lays one egg every day or every other day until she has laid two to four eggs. The male and female both incubate the eggs, which hatch after about 40 days. Because the eggs are laid one or two days apart, they also hatch one or two days apart. Chicks that hatch first are bigger than the other chicks and are usually dominant over the smaller chicks. If the parents cannot provide enough food for all of the chicks in the nest, the smallest chicks do not get enough food and sometimes die.

  • osprey-landing-with-fish_a3i0625-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey landing with large fish in talons. Canon EOS 1Dx MkII, Canon EF 600mm/f4 lens and 1.4x TC at 840mm, f6.3, 1/1600s, ISO 640, handheld.

  • Osprey-and-young-chick-on-nest_A3I0961-Lake-Blue-Cypress,-FL,-USA.jpg

Osprey on nest with three chicks. Canon EOS 1Dx MkII, Canon EF 600mm/f4 lens and 1.4x TC at 840mm, f6.3, 1/1600s, ISO 640, handheld.

When osprey chicks hatch, they are covered in white down with brown streaks on the face, back, and wings. When the chicks are 10 days old, the white down is replaced by charcoal-colored down. Chicks begin to grow feathers when they are two weeks old. Osprey chicks begin to fly when they are 48 to 76 days old. Once they can fly, osprey chicks begin to hunt for themselves, though they usually also take food from their parents until they can catch enough fish to feed themselves.

Male and female ospreys both care for their young. They feed the chicks and protect them from predators and cool, wet weather. The male provides all of the fish for the chicks before they can fly. This means that males have to catch up 10 fish each day for the female and the chicks. The parents tear the fish into small pieces for the chicks to eat. Osprey parents hunt fish for their chicks until the chicks can hunt enough fish to feed themselves. Chicks can usually feed themselves two to eight weeks after they begin flying.

  • osprey-chicks-learning-to-fly_e7t1585-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey chicks on nest flapping wings. Canon EOS 1Dx, Canon EF 600mm/f4 lens at 600mm, f4.5, 1/2500s, ISO 400, handheld.

During the first few weeks after hatching, osprey chicks cannot control their body temperature very well. The female parent broods the chicks frequently for the first two weeks and during very hot or cool weather until they are about four weeks old. Both parents spend a lot of time protecting the nest from other ospreys and potential predators.

During my visit in late April with my wife Adri, the weather was great for photography. A calm morning with easterly wind would be perfect for landing osprey on their nest in the cypress trees. As with all things in nature photography, even the best circumstances do not guarantee success.

  • osprey-with-fish-landing_e7t0884-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey landing on the nest with a fish. Canon EOS 1Dx, Canon EF 200-400mm/f4 lens with 1.4x TC at 473mm, f5.6, 1/1600s, ISO 400, handheld.

The flight activity on the northwest side of the lake was pretty decent, but the ospreys were not really cooperative, and instead of landing on the nests, they decided to wait in nearby trees, or leave the immediate area of the nests completely.

  • osprey-with-fish-against-blue-sky_e7t1386-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey in the air with a fish. Canon EOS 1Dx, Canon EF 200-400mm/f4 lens with 1.4x TC at 506mm, f5.6, 1/2000s, ISO 400, handheld.

  • osprey-with-fish-on-branch_e7t1596-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey with large fish catch on cypress tree branch. Canon EOS 1Dx, Canon EF 600mm/f4 lens at 600mm, f4.5, 1/1250s, ISO 400, handheld.

It was already late in the breeding season for the resident ospreys, as many of the chicks have hatched and are getting close to adult size. The need to protect the nest and keep the eggs warm decreases as the breeding season advances. After a slow start on the northwest side I decided to check out the south side of the lake hoping for better opportunities.

  • osprey-chick-head-portrait-with-blue-sky_44a1265-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Young osprey chick with orange eyes. Canon 7D MkII, Canon EF 600mm/f4 MkII, 600mm, 1/1600s at f9, ISO 400, handheld.

While I was photographing two grown chicks on a nest, Adri noticed a aerial chase between three ospreys well over the lake. They were too far away to get some decent flight images, even with the 600mm lens I was using for the chicks on the nest. A short while later, one of the ospreys was in the water, and was getting dive bombed by the other two ospreys.

  • osprey-with-blood-swimming-iii_44a1299-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Wounded osprey swimming with blood dripping from his nostrils. Canon 7D MkII, Canon EF 600mm/f4 MkII, 600mm, 1/1250s at f7.1, ISO 400, handheld.

  • osprey-with-blood-swimming-ii_44a1299-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Wounded osprey swimming with blood dripping from his nostrils. Canon 7D MkII, Canon EF 600mm/f4 MkII, 600mm, 1/1250s at f7.1, ISO 400, handheld.

Initially, we thought that a recently fledged chick had miscalculated its flight path and ended up in the water, and that the parents where trying to rescue the inexperienced flyer. Another possibility could be that the so-called “toe-drag” went wrong. Ospreys occasionally, drag their talons through the water to clean off dirt and nesting materials.

  • clemens-with-saved-osprey-in-towel_s6a7035-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Wounded osprey wrapped in towel. Canon EOS 5D MkII, Canon EF 24-70mm/f2.8 lens at 70mm, f7.1, 1/800s, ISO 200, handheld.

It looked like the osprey was in trouble. He was swimming in Michael Phelps style but could not get airborne. I carefully steered the boat towards him to see if he needed help. The two attacking ospreys left the scene as we came closer. Looking through my long lens I noticed that the bird was bleeding and apparently hurt.

  • osprey-with-wounds-on-nest-ii_s6a7044-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Wounded osprey recovering from his ordeal. Canon EOS 5D MkII, Canon EF 24-70mm/f2.8 lens at 61mm, f5.6, 1/320s, ISO 200, handheld.

While getting closer, he noticed the boat and changed his course towards us, as if he knew that we were there to help him. I carefully lifted him out of the water by his wings while his claws jammed into my hand. After folding his wings we wrapped a towel around him to calm him down and to be able to assess his wounds. It appeared he was bleeding from his nostrils, but other than that he had no other visible wounds.

We kept him wrapped in the towel and cleaned up his beak and nostrils to stop the bleeding. He was extremely calm and was even seeking eye contact with me, as I assured him he would be fine. It is a special feeling to experience a connection with such a beautiful wild raptor.

Although the osprey was seemingly fine, he was obviously in shock, so I had to come up with a plan. The nearest wildlife rescue center is in Stuart, more than an hour away, so that was no real option. The best plan was to put him back in his own environment at a spot where he could regain his strength and dry out. We carefully dropped him off in an abandoned nest on top of a small cypress tree closer to the lake edge. He looked relieved and confused at the same time.

  • osprey-wounded-head-portrait_s6a7047-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Wounded osprey looking pretty meshed up. Canon EOS 5D MkII, Canon EF 24-70mm/f2.8 lens at 70mm, f5.6, 1/320s, ISO 200, handheld.

We kept an eye on him for about an hour to see how he was doing, while trying to understand what really happened, and how he ended up in the water. A closer look at his feathers and the color of his eyes proved that it was not a fledgling who made an honest but possible deadly beginners mistake. In juvenile ospreys, the brown body feathers have lighter margins, thereby giving them a scaly look, which makes them easier to distinguish from the adults, and the color of the eyes is more orange than yellow. Our friend had yellow eyes and a nice pack of chocolate colored feathers, all suggesting that he was an adult bird, possible a sub-adult only 3-5 years old.

  • osprey-wounded-on-the-cypress-nest_e7t1487-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey resting on abandoned nest after swimming ordeal. Canon EOS 1Dx, Canon EF 200-400mm/f4 lens with 1.4x TC at 200mm, f6.3, 1/800s, ISO 400, handheld.

After a bit of time he started shaking and flapping his wings helping him to dry quicker. The bleeding had stopped and he looked more alive. We left him on his perch feeling confident that he would live another day.

  • osprey-with-wounds-on-nest_44a1424-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Wounded osprey drying on abandoned nest. Canon 7D MkII, Canon EF 600mm/f4 MkII and 1.4x TC, 840mm, 1/2000s at f7.1, ISO 400, handheld.

Further reading and research pointed towards a case of agonistic behavior among ospreys. Agonistic behavior is any social behavior related to fighting and it often includes threats, displays, aggression and submission. The behavior revolves mostly around defending nests against other osprey, especially in areas where the nests are located very close together, as is the case with the osprey at Lake Blue Cypress.

Defending the nest is critical and often intense when young chicks are around, and it includes calling and displays such as wing-shaking and fanned tail feathers. If that does not scare the intruder away vigorous aerial chases often ensue if the intruding osprey approaches the nest too closely. Anecdotal evidence suggests that (very rarely) individuals may be injured or even killed in such fights and aerial chases.

  • osprey-on-a-tree-with-wings-wide_e7t1353-lake-blue-cypress-fl-usa.jpg

Osprey landing on dead cypress tree. Canon EOS 1Dx, Canon EF 200-400mm/f4 lens with 1.4x TC at 560mm, f6.3, 1/2000s, ISO 400, handheld.

What we had witnessed was an aerial chase gone wrong, which started when our friend tried to intrude on an already existing nesting pair. In an attempt to defend their nest and fledglings the osprey parents went after our friend and knocked him out of the air and into the lake. We did not see this particular moment, but witnessed the dive-bombing. The bleeding was the result of the wounds inflicted during the dive-bomb attacks.

In dealing with a situation like this it is always difficult to know if you did the right thing. Interference by humans with the natural environment can lead to both good and bad things, but my initial instinct was to save an otherwise helpless bird, which would have drowned in the middle of a lake. For me it was the right decision, and we felt good about saving a beautiful raptor’s life.

What would you have done?

www.clemensvanderwerf.com